Ok, going to attempt this...

For Yu: A little stuffed kitty version of Izanagi. Plus one date because it is technically date night for Japan.

For Minato: A plush version of Messiah and a pair of glasses. They don't work against fog but it's something between purse owners.

For Tails: An assortment of cookies and chocolates thankfully not made by her. Gotta love Sugercube Corner.

For York: A couple of tins of coffee. Don't waste it!

For Flare: A hat and scarf set as well as some good pony liquor. What brand is up to Sword's choice.

For Rarity (SN): A couple of sketchbooks and supplies for future designs.

For MayTwi: A pack of tarot cards (pony version), a tea set with various tea flavors, and things to make s'mores.

For Dream Weaver (Luna): A basket full of fruits and chocolates along with a note saying the following: 'Thank you for giving me that push I needed.'